1999-2000
Coach: Jess Wilder
6th Place in NAIA Wrestling National Championships
3rd Place Finish in Great Lakes Region
Cumberland College vs. Anderson College
11/9/99
Cumberland College 30, Anderson College 16
| Weight Class | Name and School | D | Name and School | Result |
| 125 | Andy Medders (CC) | D | Wins by Forfeit | |
| 133 | Dusty Brown (CC) | D | Jorge Cuevas (AC) | 9-1 |
| 141 | Humberto Reyna (CC) | D | Ed Vasques (AC) | 14-4 |
| 149 | Kevin Case (CC) | D | Ben Howard (AC) | 13-3 |
| 157 | Ryan Alfau (CC) | D | Jeremy Mayfield (AC) | Pin (1:37) |
| 165 | Buck Buhler (AC) | D | Dan Pardon (CC) | 10-7 |
| 174 | Scott Goldstein (AC) | D | Juan Bell (AC) | 11-7 |
| 184 | Ryan Hardy (AC) | D | Johnny Matute (CC) | 18-7 |
| 197 | Rick McClain (CC) | D | Travis Gilbert (AC) | Pin (1:18) |
| HWT | Shawn Meeks (AC) | D | Michael Irving (CC) | Pin (3:24) |
Cumberland College vs. Cumberland University
1/18/00
Cumberland College 46, Cumberland University 0
| Weight Class | Name and School | D | Name and School | Result |
| 125 | Andy Medders (CC) | D | Wins by Forfeit | |
| 133 | Danny Anguiano (CC) | D | Stiff (CU) | 9-1 |
| 141 | Humberto Reyna (CC) | D | Burgess (CU) | 14-4 |
| 149 | Kevin Case (CC) | D | Grindstaff (GU) | 13-3 |
| 157 | Ryan Alfau (CC) | D | Rouse (CU) | Pin (1:37) |
| 165 | Juan Bell (CC) | D | Scruggs (CU) | 10-7 |
| 174 | Rufus (CC) | D | Brunnetti (CU) | 11-7 |
| 184 | Johnny Matute (CC) | D | Strives (CU) | 18-7 |
| 197 | Rick McClain (CC) | D | Wins by Forfeit | Pin (1:18) |
| HWT | Michael Irving (CC) | D | Leonard (CU) | Pin (3:24) |
Cumberland College vs. Gardner Webb
2/5/00
Cumberland College 34, Gardner Webb 9
| Weight Class | Name and School | D | Name and School | Result |
| 125 | Wyatt Wilkie (CC) | D | Homan (GW) | 10-6 |
| 133 | Danny Anguiano (CC) | D | Chenevey (GW) | 8-4 |
| 141 | Humberto Reyna (CC) | D | Hadgecoch (GW) | 21-8 |
| 149 | Kevin Case (CC) | D | Mullis (GW) | Pin (1:04) |
| 157 | Ryan Alfau (CC) | D | Wince (GW) | 6-3 |
| 165 | Juan Bell (CC) | D | Wince (GW) | Pin (6:26) |
| 174 | Sweet (GW) | D | Rufus (CC) | 2-1 (2OT) |
| 184 | Chambers (GW) | D | Johnny Matute (CC) | Pin (4:07) |
| 197 | Rick McClain (CC) | D | Hillmon (GW) | 9-8 |
| HWT | Michael Irving (CC) | D | Bradford (GW) | Pin (2:57) |