What one student's journey reveals about choosing a college where you'll be supported, challenged, and prepared for your future.
After nearly choosing another university, music education major Georgia Smith discovered that finding the right college wasn't about picking the closest or most familiar option. Instead, it was about finding a place where she could truly thrive. Here's what she learned and what future college students should consider during their own search.
How Do You Know if a College Is the Right Fit?
Choosing a college is one of the biggest decisions many students make after high school. It's easy to compare tuition costs, rankings, scholarship offers, or distance from home. But those factors only tell part of the story.
The best college fit often comes down to questions like:
- Will I feel supported when classes become challenging?
- Can I picture myself building friendships and community here?
- Will professors know me beyond my student ID number?
- Will this university prepare me for the career I want?
- Can I see myself growing both personally and academically?
For University of the Cumberlands senior Georgia Smith, those questions became much more important than choosing what initially seemed like the most practical option.
Sometimes the "Logical" Choice Isn't the Right One
By the beginning of her senior year of high school, Georgia Smith of Westphalia, Michigan, believed she had already made her college decision.
The university she initially chose was respected, close to home, and had already offered her scholarships. From the outside, it seemed like the obvious choice.
Still, she couldn't shake the memory of a family trip to Kentucky the previous spring and of a college that had landed on her radar because of it.
"In my junior year of high school, my parents won some tickets to visit the ARK Encounter. That year, for our spring break, we decided to make a trip of it... This was my first time visiting Kentucky, and I really enjoyed it."
Inspired by the trip, Georgia began researching colleges in Kentucky. That's when she discovered University of the Cumberlands.
"It checked all my boxes: it had the program I was interested in, a beautiful campus, was very affordable, held Christian values, was small, and just seemed like a pleasant place overall."
Even so, she assumed she'd choose the more practical option closer to home.
"But Cumberlands was still nagging at the back of my mind."
Eventually, she visited the Williamsburg campus.
"The longer the tour went on, the more and more excited I became. As we walked around campus, I just had this feeling that this was somewhere I could belong, somewhere I could really thrive."
The visit convinced Georgia to enroll. Over the next several years as a student, that first impression proved to be well-founded. Through supportive professors, meaningful friendships, hands-on learning opportunities, and faculty mentors, she found that Cumberlands exceeded her expectations.
Her experience won't be identical to every student's, but it offers a helpful framework for what prospective students can look for when searching for a college where they'll thrive.
1. The Right College Supports You Through Challenges
Many students worry that struggling academically means they aren't cut out for a program.
Georgia experienced that fear during her first year studying music education.
"I felt completely lost and behind because many of the concepts were so new to me," she recalled about her introductory music theory courses.
Instead of falling behind, she found a professor who invested in her success.
"Dr. Warfield was so incredibly helpful and patient with me; she always kindly answered my mountains of questions and gave her time outside of class to help me better understand the content."
Perhaps the greatest support Dr. Warfield offered was her unwavering encouragement.
"I knew she believed in me, and that gave me the confidence to keep working at it."
Today, Georgia tutors students in those same music theory classes.
Her experience illustrates an important lesson for prospective college students: academic success often depends not only on the curriculum but also on having professors who are willing to invest in students as individuals.
2. Community Should Extend Beyond the Classroom
For many students, finding community is just as important as choosing the right academic program.
Georgia quickly discovered opportunities to become involved across campus.
"Something I love about the Cumberlands is the uplifting community and atmosphere. I have made wonderful connections wherever I go on campus, whether through my job, classes, extracurriculars, and more."
Today, she's involved in:
- Theatre productions
- Vocal ensembles
- Community band
- Bible study
- Work-study
- Patriot Success Leader program
- Tutoring music fundamentals
- The Potato Hoppers English country dance group (Yes, it’s a thing).
Rather than belonging to a single organization, Georgia easily built community through many different interests that nurture her faith, grow her leadership skills, and increase her confidence.
3. Great Mentors Shape More Than Your Education
Georgia credits much of her growth to Professor Tara Warfield.
While Dr. Warfield helped strengthen Georgia's musicianship, her greatest impact reached beyond vocal technique.
"One of the biggest struggles in my vocal study is my perfectionism."
Georgia admits she often became discouraged whenever she made mistakes.
"Though it is still a struggle of mine, Dr. Warfield has really helped me begin to let go of my impossible standards and see the good in what I am accomplishing."
She adds:
"She makes me feel that I am not alone... and I truly feel that she listens to me."
For Georgia, that mentorship became one of the defining parts of her college experience.
"I know that Dr. Warfield truly cares about me, and I know she has played a large role in my success and well-being here at Cumberlands."
4. Real Experience Builds Career Confidence
Georgia knew she wanted to become a music educator.
University of the Cumberlands gave her opportunities to begin practicing that calling long before graduation.
"Whether it's participating in ensembles and theatre productions or taking classes focusing on choral methods, music theory, conducting, etc., I have grown so much from these opportunities."
Outside the classroom, she has gained additional experience serving as both a Patriot Success Leader and music theory tutor.
Teaching other students has strengthened both her understanding of music and her confidence as a future educator.
Rather than waiting until student teaching, Georgia has been developing practical leadership and teaching skills throughout her college experience.
What Should You Look for During a College Visit?
Georgia's story offers several practical reminders for students beginning their college search.
Ask yourself:
- Can I picture myself belonging here?
- Do professors seem invested in student success?
- Are there opportunities to get involved outside of class?
- Will this university help prepare me for my career?
- Does this campus align with my personal values and goals?
Sometimes, the answers become clear after visiting campus.
Finding the Place Where You'll Thrive
When Georgia first began applying to colleges, she believed the safest decision was the one closest to home.
Instead, she chose the university that felt like the right fit.
During her time at University of the Cumberlands, she found the supportive professors, meaningful mentorship, welcoming community, and hands-on opportunities that helped confirm she had made the right decision.
Her story isn't about taking the unconventional path. It's about finding a college where you can grow, discover your potential, and prepare for what's next.
For Georgia, that place was University of the Cumberlands.
For prospective students beginning their own college search, her experience offers an important reminder: the right college isn't always the one you planned for. It's the one where you'll be supported, challenged, and given the opportunity to thrive.
Music Education at Cumberlands
Georgia’s experience shows how studying music education can extend beyond the classroom. At University of the Cumberlands, music education students develop their musicianship while gaining practical experience through ensembles, performances, conducting, teaching preparation, and other opportunities designed to prepare them for careers as music educators.
Students also learn alongside faculty who can provide the individualized instruction, mentorship, and encouragement that are central to the Cumberlands experience.
Explore the Music Education program at University of the Cumberlands.